This is a solid 4.8/4.7 from me, but I've leaned towards 4 just because 5 means it's perfect and above and beyond. It is verrrrry near that mark though. My little girl, who is almost 2, gravitated to this and was satisfied to sit and look at each and every picture. So unfortunately, even though I had every intention of screening it, we went through it the first time together. Lol. The great thing is that most of these pictures are really great for, like it says, explaining and identifying social situations, and I love that they considered diversity as well. I saw at least one picture with what I think was an interracial couple, and as a lady with a mixed child, I can't tell you how prized that is and how grateful I feel that my little girl would see our little family reflected elsewhere in print, even if it's not exactly the same. So great. My little one is a little too young for us to use the questions just yet, so I didn't pay as much attention to them, but I did scan a couple and I think they are GREAT for an older child. I also really love the idea they pitched of using these for storytelling. I have dabbled in writing myself, and getting the creative juices flowing can be difficult. To start that kind of curiosity and imagination in a child is just... gold. You get to take that kind of creativity with you everywhere! So great. The card quality itself is also good. Not too thick, not too thin. The cards fit into the box they come in. The only bummer for me is that a handful of images seem to be encouraging or reinforcing ideas that I don't want to put into my child's head. Now... let's get this straight. I think they did a GREAT job including every day pictures (a lot of them are kind of stock and staged and nicey-nicey, but)... I LOVE for example, that they have an image on bullying. That's something you're just going to see and what a great way to get to start talking about that in a safe environment. I also love that there is an image of two girls (maybe siblings even), fighting over a toy. Again, this is something a child would very likely see-- even at school or a friends' house, and again I think it's great to have this game as a way to start talking about that. But then there are some things I don't want to put into my child's head: like being afraid of the dark, vegetables not being the absolute worst, getting on top of stools or chairs to get something that a parent has said no to and breaking things... I felt a little more on edge with these pictures and thought, "Dang! Wish I had screened these and taken those out first!" Even at her age, I just don't want these things to be soaked up. Now, you could argue that these things are ALSO things that a child may see and that these are ALSO an opportunity to talk about them... but it is what it is. Not my cup of tea. Still, I think that the game makers always run this risk, and so I appreciate and applaud their bravery in making the game anyway. I maybe wish that some of those tropes had been altered slightly or flipped on their head so that they weren't sustaining an age old idea (being scared of the dark; veggies are nasty). Why not show an image of a kid rejecting some kind of slop vs veggies? Or being scared of SOMEthing but not necessarily the dark? I don't know. Sorry. Off talking about it again. All in all, this is really fantastic and I think they did a standout job. If I were in love with every picture, it would probably be strange, wouldn't it...? So maybe it's only to be expected that a 4.7 would come from every customer. Well done, game makers. I can't wait until my little one and I start to have real conversations about these vs me just talking at my little girl and her getting a kick out of the pictures. :) Amazon Customer